Natural & Organic Mascara Roundup

This post may contain affiliate links, and I will earn a commission if you purchase through these links. Please read the disclosure policy for more details.

If you are looking for a natural or organic mascara you might be surprised to find that there are quite a few decent options out there.

I have tried so many – from $40 to $5 mascaras and I will say that more expensive does not always mean better. There are a few great affordable mascaras.

In this post, I will share my thoughts on some of the most affordable clean natural and organic mascaras that you can find in drugstores and online, as well as some popular high end options.

Honest Beauty Mascara

Ok, so I’m starting off with the BEST natural mascara! This mascara is my favorite. It gives a very dramatic look with voluminous and long lashes. At first, it is very wet, which I had to get used to. But with time it dries a bit and applies less wet. I only need one coat of this mascara and it lasts all day.

I also love that it comes with a primer on one end, which helps condition lashes and adds bulk for length and volume. Both brushes are silicone.

Another plus, it’s under $15! You can shop for this mascara on Amazon or your local Target. Shop for it here.

Honest Beauty 2-in-1 Extreme Length Clean Mascara + Lash Primer
Shop on Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
03/04/2024 05:17 pm GMT
Delilah Orpi shows what she looks like with Honest Beauty natural mascara - natural mascara, organic mascara, green beauty, clean beauty
wearing 1 coat of Honest Beauty mascara

Pacifica Stellar Gaze

Woman holding Pacifica Stellar Gaze mascara opened in her hand

This mascara is very lengthening and gives a nice natural look. When I tried it I applied several coats to try to achieve thicker lashes but it doesn’t do much for volume. It does add lots of length and definition. I usually prefer more drama so this one is not one I go to often, but it is a very popular and affordable clean mascara for those who just want length, separation, and a natural look.

It wears well, doesn’t flake, and applies nicely. It’s a wet formula.

You can shop Pacifica Beauty in some drug stores, Amazon, and Target. They actually have a few different mascaras but Stellar Gaze is the only one I have tried. You can buy it here.

Physician’s Formula Organic Wear Natural Origin Mascara

Delilah Orpi shows what she looks like wearing Pacifica Stellar Gaze mascara review
wearing 3 coats of Pacifica Stellar Gaze mascara

This mascara is available at many drug stores like CVS making it a great, accessible option. Another mascara with a natural finish, this will add some length and a little volume but nothing dramatic. It is said to be great for those with sensitive eyes. The tube also dries quickly so it will not last as long as others.

It’s also a steal at under $10! Shop for it here.

Burt’s Bees Nourishing Mascara

Another very natural looking mascara. It separates and adds length but little volume. It is a drier formula so reapplication gets clumpy. It also has a silicone brush. I noticed a bit of flaking with application.

They have a nourishing and volumizing option. Shop for it here.

ILIA Limitless Lash Mascara – mini

Woman's hand holding Ilia Limitless mascara
ILIA Limitless Mascara

ILIA Limitless Lash is one of the most popular mascaras in the green beauty world. It adds the perfect amount of length and volume, doesn’t clump, and lasts all day. It has a unique brush that does really well at separating lashes but sometimes can stab while I’m applying.

The full size is more expensive but the mini is only $13! I say give the mini and try and you might see yourself wanting to pay for the full size!

Delilah wearing two coats of Ilia Limitless mascara review
wearing 2 coats of Ilia Limitless mascara

Honeybee Gardens Truly Natural Mascara

Yet another natural looking mascara (noticing a theme here?). It is water-resistant, not waterproof, and adds good length and definition. It is wet but dries quickly and a second coat applies easily. Some people do complain that it smudges but that did not happen to me. You can buy it here.

Some of my other favorites

I’m including a few mascaras that are in the $20-$30 price range for those who are looking for more high quality ingredients.

Hynt Beauty Nocturne Mascara

woman's hand holding Hynt Beauty Nocturne mascara

Nocturne is one of my favorite high end mascaras. It gives a less dramatic finish than Honest Beauty but still adds length and volumizes. It’s a fluffier, full look. This mascara is drier but it lasts a long time. It applies wet but dries quickly. I have noticed recently that it sometimes smudges later in the day if it’s really hot or humid. But I feel like it’s the perfect balance between drama and natural. Shop for it here.

Delilah Orpi shows what she looks like wearing two coats of Hynt Beauty mascara, organic mascara, natural mascara
Wearing 2 coats of Hynt Beauty mascara

Harvest Natural Beauty Lengthening Mascara

woman holding Harvest Natural Beauty mascara in her hand

This mascara is like a more affordable version of Hynt, but it’s also water-resistant. It applies the same way and gives a similar finish. But it is a bit more stubborn to remove though so it’s great for anyone who struggles with natural mascaras smudging. Shop for it here.

Delilah Orpi showing the results of two coats of  Harvest Natural Beauty water resistant mascara
wearing 2 coats of Harvest Natural Beauty mascara

100% Pure Maracuja Oil Lengthening Mascara

woman's hand holding 100% Pure Maracuja mascara

This mascara gives a more natural look. It’s a great dependable mascara that lengthens and defines without smudging or flaking. It’s a wet formula with a natural brush. Shop for it here.

Delilah wearing three coats of 100% Pure Maracuja mascara
wearing 3 coats of 100% Pure mascara

Fit Glow Beauty Good Lash Mascara

woman's hand holding an open tube of Fit Glow good length mascara
Fit Glow beauty Good Lash Mascara

This is a mascara that I have been hearing about for years but I simply refused to spend over $30 on a mascara (it costs $38). Luckily, I got it in a Petit Vour box and now I see what all the fuss is about.

It lengthens, adds volume, and defines lashes very well while staying put all day. It still looks natural but very close to the drama I get from Honest Beauty mascara. It does dry quickly so you have to work quickly with this one if you want to apply several coats.

I think it’s one of the best green beauty mascaras but I’m not sure it’s worth the price tag. It is supposed to help your lashes grow as well so maybe if it truly does do that it would be worth it. Shop for it here.

Delilah Orpi wearing two coats of Fit Glow Good lash mascara
wearing 2 coats of Fit Glow Beauty Good Lash mascara

Sappho New Paradigm Mascara

Sappho New Paradigm mascara review clean beauty
Sappho New Paradigm mascara

Sappho New Paradigm is another one that has a good reputation, but also a big price tag. This mascara is $34 and it is really good too. The brush is very similar to the ILIA Limitless Lash mascara and honestly, it performs the same. With ILIA being nearly $10 less I’d go for ILIA. Shop the Sappho mascara here.

Delilah Orpi wearing two coats of Sappho New Paradigm mascara review clean beauty
wearing 2 coats of Sappho New Paradigm

I hope you enjoyed Natural & Organic Mascaras Roundup. For more clean beauty, check out my other popular posts:

And subscribe to my YouTube channel!

Looking for more budget natural beauty products?

In addition to reading my posts on affordable clean beauty, be sure to join my email list to access my clean beauty shopping guides and more in my freebies library!

Want to remember this? Save Natural & Organic Mascara Roundup to your favorite Pinterest board!

Delilah smiling and holding her favorite affordable natural and organic mascara
10 natural and organic mascaras

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *